|
|
||||||||
RAPID COMMUNICATION |
Department of Preventive and Restorative Dental Sciences, University of California, San Francisco;
*corresponding author, Department of Mechanical Engineering, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, L-333, University of California, Livermore, CA 94551, kinney3{at}llnl.gov
| ABSTRACT |
|---|
|
|
|---|
KEY WORDS: dentin Youngs modulus hardness mineralization collagen
| INTRODUCTION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
c,
im, and
em are the volume fractions of collagen, intrafibrillar, and extrafibrillar mineral, respectively, then the Youngs modulus of the tissue is approximated by (Pidaparti et al., 1996):
![]() | (1) |
In 1, ao is the elastic stiffness of the unmineralized collagen, and Cm is the elastic stiffness (C11) of the pure hydroxyapatite phase. This model predicts that the elastic stiffness will increase with increasing mineral concentration, implying that the elastic properties of a demineralized collagen scaffold can be restored through remineralization.
The major difficulty with the above analysis is that the model, particularly its treatment of mineral partitioning, has never been rigorously tested. In particular, while it might be relatively straightforward to remineralize the extrafibrillar compartments, restriction of access might make it difficult to remineralize the gap zones within the interior of the collagen fibrils. In the absence of intrafibrillar mineral, Eq. 1 reduces to:
![]() | (2) |
Thus, the elastic properties of the tissue could be restored by increasing the amount of extrafibrillar mineral, even without the contribution of the intrafibrillar mineral. Unfortunately, it is difficult to conceive of an experiment that could elucidate the separate contributions of the intra- and extrafibrillar mineral.
In an earlier study, we provided evidence that intrafibrillar mineralization may be absent in dentinogenesis imperfecta (DI-II) dentin (Kinney et al., 2001a), and proposed that this altered form of dentin might provide a unique resource for studying the mechanical importance of extrafibrillar mineral in isolation. Regardless of whether these specimens reflected the true nature of DI-II, since the population of teeth was so small, no evidence of intrafibrillar mineral was found, yet at the same time the extrafibrillar mineral appeared normal in crystallite size, consistent with earlier findings in DI-II dentin (Kerebel et al., 1981). Therefore, in this study we measured the hardness and indentation Youngs modulus of this altered dentin to test the hypothesis that the elastic modulus is linear in the mineral concentration (Eqs. 1 and 2), and to measure the separate contribution of extrafibrillar mineral to the elastic properties of dentin. A positive outcome would justify using the mineral concentration as an endpoint for assessing the success or failure of remineralization approaches in restorative dentistry.
| MATERIALS & METHODS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Specimens
Four unerupted and intact human third molars were obtained from the UCSF Dental Hard Tissue Specimen Bank, and we certify that the use of the teeth conformed to an informed consent protocol approved by the Institutional Review Boards of the University of California-San Francisco, Lawrence Livermore National Laboratory, and Stanford University. The donors were female and ranged in age from 18 to 21 yrs old. The altered dentin specimens came from a single female donor, age 20 yrs, with a clinical diagnosis of dentinogenesis imperfecta type II (DI-II) based on physical evidence (see Table
) as well as a family history of this trait and no clinical or familial evidence of osteogenesis imperfecta (OI). The altered specimens were unerupted third molars, and the enamel was largely intact. After extraction, the teeth were sterilized with gamma irradiation. All teeth, both altered and normal controls, were stored under identical conditions in de-ionized water at 4°C.
|
The image data were reconstructed into three-dimensional mappings of the x-ray opacity with Fourier-filtered back-projection. The x-ray opacities were converted to mineral concentration by methods described in a previous study (Kinney et al., 2000).
AFM Indentations
After images were made, 1-mm-thick specimens were cut from the teeth about 1 mm superior to the cervical margin, leaving the peripheral enamel intact. After performing small-angle x-ray scattering (Kinney et al., 2001a), we glued the specimens onto a metal disk and polished them with a succession of SiO2 papers and diamond paste; final polishing was with 0.25-µm paste.
Specimens were studied with the use of an atomic force microscope (Nanoscope III Digital Instruments, Santa Barbara, CA, USA) with the standard head replaced with a Triboscope indenter system (Hysitron Inc., Minneapolis, MN, USA), as described elsewhere (Balooch et al., 1998; Marshall et al., 2001). A liquid cell Berkovich diamond indenter was used for indentation and imaging. Fused silica was used to calibrate the indentation Youngs modulus and to define the tip area function for indentation depths between 30 and 240 nm. Loads were adjusted to maintain the indentation depth between 150 and 200 nm, which required a load of 400 µN for normal hydrated and dehydrated dentin, as well as for the dehydrated altered dentin. For the altered dentin in its hydrated state, the load was lowered to 200 µN.
Specimens were first tested in the hydrated state by immersion in de-ionized water in a liquid cell. Subsequently, specimens were dehydrated by air-blowing and dried at room temperature for at least 1 hr prior to being re-tested. From the load-displacement data, the hardness, H, and the indentation Youngs modulus, E, were determined (Oliver and Pharr, 1992). A minimum of 25 indentations was performed on the intertubular dentin of each specimen. These 25+ measurements at each location were averaged, and paired two-tailed t tests were applied to these averages to test for significant differences between specimens.
| RESULTS |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The indentation Youngs modulus of dry normal dentin was 23.9 (SD = 1.1) GPa; the modulus decreased by 15%, or 3.9 GPa, with wetting. This decrease was significant (p < 0.001). The indentation Youngs modulus of dry DI+ dentin was 20.4 (1.8) GPa; the modulus decreased by nearly a factor of four with wetting. The modulus of the less mineralized altered dentin (DI) was 13.8 (2.0) GPa; the modulus decreased nearly three-fold with wetting. A box plot displaying the results of all indentations is shown in Fig. 1
.
|
|
|
| DISCUSSION |
|---|
|
|
|---|
The hardness of normal dentin did not appear to depend on water content. The hardness of the altered dentin, on the other hand, exhibited the same, anomalous, hydration behavior as the Youngs modulus. In normal dentin, it appears that the effects of the decreased yield strength must be coupled with the decreased elastic modulus in such a way that the hardness remains constant. This coupling must be broken in the absence of intrafibrillar mineralization.
Since dentin is hydrated in the oral environment, the lack of correlation of elasticity and hardness with mineral density is troubling. Current research is increasingly oriented toward efforts to arrest and re-mineralize caries lesions in dentin with either solution chemistry or more fundamental tissue engineering approaches (Mellberg and Sanchez, 1986; Clarkson and Rafter, 2001; Lynch and Baysan, 2001; ten Cate, 2001). Though remineralization of enamel shows great potential (Shen et al., 2001; Lagerweij and ten Cate, 2002), the results of this study raise doubt as to whether mineral concentration alone is an appropriate endpoint for assessing the success or failure of these approaches in dentin. It would appear, instead, that a more appropriate endpoint in remineralization studies should be the establishment of mechanical properties consistent with the normal tissue. While in certain circumstances it might be possible to achieve high elastic moduli and abrasion resistance with low concentrations of mineral (Lichtenegger et al., 2002), it now appears that there are circumstances where dentin can display low elastic moduli and abrasion resistance in spite of near-normal (90%) levels of mineral concentration.
To explain these experimental observations, we propose that the traditional approach of treating the extrafibrillar mineral as linear elastic should be reconsidered. We hypothesize instead that the extrafibrillar mineral is granular, and that the contacts between the crystalline grains are highly compliant due to moisture or attached proteins. This unconsolidated granular phase is held together and reinforced by interpenetrating collagen fibrils. The intrafibrillar mineral, which stiffens the collagen fibrils, dominates the elastic behavior under normal loading conditions. With drying, however, small contractions in the collagen fibrils impose compressive stresses that consolidate the granular matrix. Compression of the granular matrix, which acquires rigidity solely as a result of these shrinkage stresses (Norris and Johnson, 1997), may be responsible for the observed increases in the Youngs modulus with drying. In the absence of intrafibrillar mineralization, the elastic constants are determined by the compliant contacts of the extrafibrillar mineral, and are therefore quite low when hydrated. With drying, however, the decrease in the contact compliance, combined with possible compressive stresses induced by the shrinking of the unmineralized collagen fibrils, could account for the observed dependence of the elastic modulus with mineral concentration. In principle, this hypothesis is testable; there should be a measurable pressure dependence of the elastic constants. This test, however, will require more specimens than we can access at this time.
Because all of the altered dentin specimens were from a single patient, we caution against inferring that our results are representative of dentin in all patients with DI-II, even though both clinical and histological findings were consistent with DI-II (Malmgren et al., 1988; Waltimo et al., 1995; Modesto et al., 1996). However, in the altered dentin examined in this study, we were unable to detect intrafibrillar mineral (Kinney et al., 2001a). Therefore, we expect that the absence of intrafibrillar mineralization would lead to similar, anomalous, behavior regardless of the dentin pathology. In addition, since dentin is a naturally hydrated biological composite of collagen and apatite similar to other calcified tissues such as cementum and bone, it will be important to determine if the same findings can be generalized to these other tissues. Further study is warranted.
In summary, we have shown that when intrafibrillar mineralization is absent, the expected linear relationship between mineral concentration and Youngs modulus or hardness vanishes. Further research into the coupling between the collagen and mineral phases is warranted.
| ACKNOWLEDGMENTS |
|---|
Received January 7, 2003; Last revision September 11, 2003; Accepted September 29, 2003
| REFERENCES |
|---|
|
|
|---|
Bonar LC, Lees S, Mook HA (1985). Neutron diffraction studies of collagen in fully mineralized bone. J Mol Biol 181:265270.[ISI][Medline]
Clarkson BH, Rafter ME (2001). Emerging methods used in the prevention and repair of carious tissues. J Dent Educ 65:11141120.[Abstract]
Kerebel B, Daculsi G, Menanteau J, Kerebel LM (1981). The inorganic phase in dentinogenesis imperfecta. J Dent Res 60:16551660.
Kinney JH, Haupt DL, Nichols MC, Breunig TM, Marshall GW, Marshall SJ (1994). The x-ray tomographic microscope3-dimensional perspectives of evolving microstructures. Nucl Inst Meth Physics Res (A) 347:480486.
Kinney JH, Haupt DL, Balooch M, Ladd AJC, Ryaby JT, Lane NE (2000). Three-dimensional morphometry of the L6 vertebra in the ovariectomized rat model of osteoporosis: biomechanical implications. J Bone Miner Res 15:19811991.[ISI][Medline]
Kinney JH, Pople JA, Driessen CK, Breunig TM, Marshall GW, Marshall SJ (2001a). Intrafibrillar mineral may be absent in dentinogenesis imperfecta type II (DI-II). J Dent Res 80:15551559.
Kinney JH, Pople JA, Marshall GW, Marshall SJ (2001b). Collagen orientation and crystallite size in human dentin: a small angle x-ray scattering study. Calcif Tissue Int 69:3137.[ISI][Medline]
Lagerweij MD, ten Cate JM (2002). Remineralisation of enamel lesions with daily applications of a high-concentration fluoride gel and a fluoridated toothpaste: an in situ study. Caries Res 36:270274.[ISI][Medline]
Landis WJ, Hodgens KJ, Arena J, Song MJ, McEwen BF (1996). Structural relations between collagen and mineral in bone as determined by high voltage electron microscopic tomography. Microsc Res Tech 33:192202.[ISI][Medline]
Lichtenegger HC, Schoberl T, Bartl MH, Waite H, Stucky GD (2002). High abrasion resistance with sparse mineralization: copper biomineral in worm jaws. Science 298:389392.
Lynch E, Baysan A (2001). Reversal of primary root caries using a dentifrice with a high fluoride content. Caries Res 35:6064.
Malmgren B, Lundberg M, Lindskog S (1988). Dentinogenesis imperfecta in a six-generation family. A clinical, radiographic and histologic comparison of two branches through three generations. Swed Dent J 120:7384.
Marshall GW Jr, Balooch M, Gallagher RR, Gansky SA, Marshall SJ (2001). Mechanical properties of the dentinoenamel junction: AFM studies of nanohardness, elastic modulus, and fracture. J Biomed Mater Res 54:8795.[ISI][Medline]
Mellberg JR, Sanchez M (1986). Remineralization by a monofluorophosphate dentifrice in vitro of root dentin softened by artificial caries. J Dent Res 65:959962.
Modesto A, Alves AC, Vieira AR, Portella W (1996). Dentinogenesis imperfecta type II: case report. Brazil Dent J 7:4752.
Norris AN, Johnson DL (1997). Nonlinear elasticity of granular media. J Appl Mechan 64:3949.
Oliver WC, Pharr GM (1992). An improved technique for determining hardness and elastic modulus using load and displacement sensing indentation experiments. J Mater Res 7:15641583.
Pidaparti RM, Chandran A, Takano Y, Turner CH (1996). Bone mineral lies mainly outside collagen fibrils: predictions of a composite model for osteonal bone. J Biomech 29:909916.[ISI][Medline]
Shen P, Cai F, Nowicki A, Vincent J, Reynolds EC (2001). Remineralization of enamel subsurface lesions by sugar-free chewing gum containing casein phosphopeptide-amorphous calcium phosphate. J Dent Res 80:20662070.
ten Cate JM (2001). Remineralization of caries lesions extending into dentin. J Dent Res 80:14071411.
Waltimo J, Ranta H, Lukinmaa PL (1995). Ultrastructure of dentin matrix in heritable dentin defects. Scanning Microsc 9:185197.[ISI][Medline]
This article has been cited by other articles:
![]() |
Y. Shibata, L.H. He, Y. Kataoka, T. Miyazaki, and M.V. Swain Micromechanical Property Recovery of Human Carious Dentin Achieved with Colloidal Nano-{beta}-tricalcium Phosphate J. Dent. Res., March 1, 2008; 87(3): 233 - 237. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
C.J. Soares, P.V. Soares, P.C.F. Santos-Filho, and S.R. Armstrong Microtensile Specimen Attachment and Shape Finite Element Analysis J. Dent. Res., January 1, 2008; 87(1): 89 - 93. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
L.E. Tam and A. Noroozi Effects of Direct and Indirect Bleach on Dentin Fracture Toughness J. Dent. Res., December 1, 2007; 86(12): 1193 - 1197. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
G.E. L. Franco, A. Huang, N. P. Camacho, D.S. Stone, and R.D. Blank Increased Young's Modulus and Hardness of Col1a2oim Dentin. J. Dent. Res., November 1, 2006; 85(11): 1032 - 1036. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
P. Suppa, A. Ruggeri Jr., F.R. Tay, C. Prati, M. Biasotto, M. Falconi, D.H. Pashley, and L. Breschi Reduced Antigenicity of Type I Collagen and Proteoglycans in Sclerotic Dentin J. Dent. Res., February 1, 2006; 85(2): 133 - 137. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
Y. Nishitani, M. Yoshiyama, F.R. Tay, B. Wadgaonkar, J. Waller, K. Agee, and D.H. Pashley Tensile Strength of Mineralized/Demineralized Human Normal and Carious Dentin J. Dent. Res., November 1, 2005; 84(11): 1075 - 1078. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
H. Nakamura, L. Saruwatari, H. Aita, K. Takeuchi, and T. Ogawa Molecular and Biomechanical Characterization of Mineralized Tissue by Dental Pulp Cells on Titanium J. Dent. Res., June 1, 2005; 84(6): 515 - 520. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
![]() |
N. Donmez, S. Belli, D.H. Pashley, and F.R. Tay Ultrastructural Correlates of in vivo/in vitro Bond Degradation in Self-etch Adhesives J. Dent. Res., April 1, 2005; 84(4): 355 - 359. [Abstract] [Full Text] [PDF] |
||||
| ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
| HOME | HELP | FEEDBACK | SUBSCRIPTIONS | ARCHIVE | SEARCH | TABLE OF CONTENTS |
| IADR Journals | Advances in Dental Research ® |
| Journal of Dental Research ® | Critical Reviews (1990-2004) |