
View larger version (28K):
[in this window]
[in a new window]
|
Figure 2. Flow curves, mathematical models validation, and results of the bending tests and finite element simulations. (A) Plot of the "multi-linear material property" flow curves (in which each stress-strain curve is represented by connected successive lines of decreased slope) used in the finite element analysis for clasps made from the 3 alloys. The 458-MPa, 685-MPa, and 883-MPa underlined values represent the proportional limit values used for Gold Type IV, Co-Cr, and Ti-6Al-7Nb alloys, respectively. The elastic modulus values were 229 GPa, 92.6 GPa, and 115.8 GPa for Co-Cr, Gold Type IV, and Ti-6Al-7Nb alloys, respectively. (B) Plot of real deflection-predicted deflection corresponding to different levels of permanent deformation for the 9 bending test specimens and their corresponding simulation models (3 specimens for each alloy). The straight line represents an ideal relation when the predicted and real values match perfectly. (C) Plot of [ Permanent deformation/ von Mises (VM) plastic strain] ratios as a function of von Mises (VM) plastic strain on the inner upper corner of 3 representative models for the 3 alloys. (D) Plot of [ von Mises (VM) residual elastic strain/ von Mises (VM) plastic strain] ratios as a function of von Mises (VM) plastic strain on the inner upper corner of 3 representative models for the 3 alloys. (E) Plot of permanent deformation as a function of deflection for the 9 bending test specimens (3 specimens for each alloy). The average amount of deflection at which permanent deformation started to appear was 275 ± 12 µm, 490 ± 18 µm, and 656 ± 13 µm for Co-Cr, Gold Type IV, and Ti-6Al-7Nb alloy clasps, respectively. (F) This Fig. shows the changes in the first principle stress value (S1 -maximum tensile stress) for a representative Ti-6Al-7Nb model. The maximum S1 in the clasp and the S1 at the inner upper corner were recorded when the model was deflected from its rest position for 0.5 mm after each permanent deformation increment. The amount of reduction in the S1 value at the inner upper corner of the clasp was almost equal to the absolute value of residual 3rd principle stress (S3 - maximum compressive stress) there.
|